CryptoReg Insight: SEC Ballet on Bitcoin ETFs

The labyrinthine world of cryptocurrency is currently under the scrutiny of the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), where the evaluation of proposed Franklin Templeton and Hashdex spot Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) applications has taken center stage.

Rumors abound within the industry, suggesting that the SEC's recent maneuvers might serve as a precursor for potential approvals of spot Bitcoin ETFs, an eagerly awaited development anticipated to unfold in the early days of January 2024. This speculation gains momentum in the wake of delayed decisions on applications from two potential issuers, injecting an air of suspense into the regulatory landscape.

SEC Invites Input from the Public

In a document filed on the 28th of November, the SEC has extended an invitation for written comments on the labyrinthine proposals put forth by Franklin Templeton and Hashdex. These comments are intended to shape the destiny of their Forms 19b-4, documents that stand apart from the more familiar Form S-1. The former serves as a publicly disclosed dossier approved by the SEC's Trading and Markets Division, while the latter, the Form S-1, awaits the imprimatur of the Corporate Finance Division. A 35-day open period for comments and responses, following publication in the Federal Register, adds a layer of procedural complexity to the regulatory ballet.

Turning our attention to the Franklin Templeton application, commentators are beckoned to delve into the intricate nuances of potential price manipulations in the volatile Bitcoin market. The spotlight also falls on the company's surveillance-sharing agreement with Coinbase, a strategic alliance woven to aid in the delicate dance of price discovery and the vigilant detection of fraudulent activities. Additionally, the correlation between BTC spot and futures prices is an enigma that commenters are summoned to unravel.

In contrast, the Hashdex proposal unfurls a more elaborate fund structure, resembling a cryptographic tapestry woven with futures ETF intricacies that cradle spot BTC. Unlike its counterpart, Franklin Templeton, Hashdex plots a course to acquire BTC from diverse exchanges on the CME, tethering its fate solely to this mechanism for pricing. The SEC, ever inquisitive, seeks input on the ponderous significance of CME's size in relation to the fund structure and the ever-elusive availability of sufficient liquidity in this digital financial realm.

The SEC's Premature Announcement Ignites Speculation

Delving even deeper, commentators are urged to navigate the labyrinth of questions surrounding sponsor Toroso Investments' meticulous calculations. These calculations form the compass directing the relationship between BTC prices on the CME and the unregulated byways of other exchanges, as the sponsor assumes the role of both manager and guardian of the fund.

The SEC's recent update, akin to a ripple in the digital pond, has sparked speculation and ripples across the crypto landscape. Rule changes ushering in the trading of these ETFs were set adrift in late September, with the Hashdex ETF poised to pirouette on the New York Stock Exchange Arca and Franklin Templeton's poised for a ballet on Cboe BZX. Notably, the SEC, akin to a temporal sorcerer, extended its decision deadline for these applications to November 15, disrupting the chronological cadence that was initially harmonized with the turning of the calendar to 2024.

James Seyffart, an expert navigator through the intricate currents of ETFs, suggests that this early temporal distortion might signal the SEC's orchestration of applications, orchestrating a symphony of approvals for all 12 issuers, a crescendo that includes the industry behemoths, BlackRock and Grayscale.

As anticipation mounts for the unfolding drama, with the probable approval date staged for the inaugural weeks of January, these prognostications are anchored in the currents of SEC procedures but must be approached with caution, for they do not wield the authority of a definitive timeline for the looming decisions.

Okay. This delay on @hashdex all but confirms for me that this was likely a move to line every applicant up for potential approval by the Jan 10, 2024 deadline. https://t.co/ZKmVSOQExk

— James Seyffart (@JSeyff) November 28, 2023

Meanwhile, in the midst of this regulatory ballet, the price of Bitcoin, the enigmatic star of this financial performance, soared by 3% at the time of reporting, its digital silhouette casting a shadow above the $38,000 threshold. Bitcoin, like a seasoned actor, has graced the financial stage with three consecutive positive months, its performance buoyed by the optimistic script foretelling the potential approval of spot Bitcoin ETFs. The market watches with bated breath, as the regulatory drama unfolds against the backdrop of a dynamic and ever-evolving digital landscape.

Read more about: CryptoChronicle: DEX Drama Unveiled